| Difference in Swingweight* | Graphite Shafted Clubs | Steel Shafted Clubs | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free Estimator | Paid Estimator | Free Estimator | Paid Estimator | |
| 0 | 27% | 53% | 33% | 49% |
| within + / -1 point | 68% | 98% | 83% | 95% |
| within + / -2 points | 95% | 100% | 100% | 100% |
Clubmakers Calculator is significantly more accurate than the Swingweight Estimatir Basic Free, particularly for graphite shafted clubs. That’s because Clubmakers Calculator takes into consideration shaft balance points, and the actual range in balance points (from low to high) is more dispersed for graphite than for steel. The following example demonstrates the variance in estimated results for different balance points.
Example 1: A driver 45" long with a graphite shaft shows a 4 point spread in swingweight of D1 to D5 for shafts of identical lengths and weights, but with extremes of shaft balance points. The "Low", "Mid" and "High" rows in the table below show the estimated results using three different shaft balance points. Clubmakers Calculator can accommodate actual balance points within the extremes of low to high. The Basic Free version is programmed with an average shaft balance point corresponding to only the mid-range, thus limiting its accuracy.
| Shaft Balance Points | Weights | Estimator Results | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Head | Uncut Shaft (46" long) | Grip | Club Balance Point | Swingweight | |
| High | 197g | 76g | 50g | 12.2 | D1 |
| Mid | 197g | 76g | 50g | 11.9 | D3 |
| Low | 197g | 76g | 50g | 11.5 | D5 |
To achieve the greatest accuracy in estimating swingweights, you must use actual weights of pre-assembled components, preferably weighed with a gram scale. It is important to be aware that specified component weights listed in a catalog are nominal and that actual weights will vary due to manufacturing tolerances. The following example demonstrates how much swingweight can vary with extremes in actual weights.
Example 2: A driver 44.5" long with a graphite shaft shows a 4 point spread in swingweight of C9 to D3 within the tolerances of the catalog’s specified weights. The "Limit 1" row in the following table is with head and shaft weights lower than specified, while the grip weight is higher than specified. "Limit 2" is the opposite extreme.
| Weights | Estimator Results | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Head | Uncut Shaft (45" long) | Grip | Club Balance Point | Swingweight | |
| Limit 1 | 196g | 79g | 52 | 12.2" | C9 |
| Specified | 198g | 80g | 50 | 12" | D1 |
| Limit 2 | 200g | 81g | 48 | 11.8" | D3 |
The program is called an "Estimator" because it does just that – it estimates values to give a reasonable approximation of results before assembling clubs. Because of the wide variations in head models and designs, it’s impossible to estimate every pre-assembled club to the exact final swingweight.